Penn State Scandal: the Biggest Sports Story Ever?

Photo Courtesy of Flickr Creative Commons

Last week, I was trying to think of where the Penn State scandal stacks up related to other major stories we have seen in the history of sports. After careful consideration, I think all other sports stories pale in comparison to what we have seen over the last week and a half.

I can think of three primary categories under which all major sports stories fall.

Infamy in sports seems to be things to which we can ascribe great social significance; notorious events, such as scandals; or specific moments when greatness is achieved.

With Penn State, the molestation scandal has directly led to the firing of the winningest coach in the history of college football. A football program, an athletic department, and a university seemed to have attempted to sweep a pedophile under the proverbial rug.

This scandal has cast a shadow on Penn State football that I’m not sure they will ever be truly freed from. The scarlet letter will brand this program so much so that, even many years from now, as a person watches a Penn State football game, the recollections of what has happened and the ugliness that occurred will come to mind.

As I have said, there are different categories under which major sports stories fall. To look at each of those briefly:

1. Events of social significance
examples: the Miracle on Ice when America beat the amazing USSR hockey team during the Cold War in the Olympics
Jesse Owens winning 4 Olympic Gold Medals in Hitler’s Germany
Jackie Robinson breaking the color barrier

As we look at the major events in American history, often times there can be events found within the sporting world that sort of symbolize the moment.

While these deserve to be considered great moments in sports, they are often times that, to be blunt, had little actual impact. Sure, it was good for American morale that we beat the hated Russians, but if Team USA had lost or had the game never been played, it’s not like the outcome of the Cold War and modern history would have been irrevocably changed.

I don’t think it’s that the sports are significant in themselves, I think it’s that we look for significance, and when something in sports can be applied to society as a whole, I think a natural reaction can be intertwining the two.

2. Classic Moments
examples: Babe Ruth “calling his shot”
NC State winning the NCAA basketball championship on a last second play
the Doug Flutie Hail Mary to lead Boston College to victory over Miami

These moments are great, and the excitement and wonder of what can happen is a part of why so many people love sports. But I think that these events are ultimately secondary to the greater context of the specific games in which they were played.

Look at it like this. Every week, there are amazing plays made in the various sports. But the vast majority of them aren’t significant longterm and won’t be replayed after a few days.

With classical sports moments, it’s not that the plays themselves are any more special than what you could see any given day, it’s the fact that the stage is unique.

3. Notorious events and scandals
examples: SMU and the Death Penalty
Baylor basketball murder
Tiger Woods affairs

SMU football will always be associated with their rampant rules violations in the 1980 which caused the NCAA to give them the “death penalty (i.e. they heavily sanctioned them to a much higher degree than what had ever been done before in college athletics. These penalties set the SMU program back so far that it has only been over the past couple seasons that they are again finding any sense of legitimacy on the field.

While SMU was significant in football, the issue wasn’t pedophilia, and SMU never had anything close to the reputation that Penn State football has in terms of integrity and football tradition.

SMU also didn’t have the iconic, larger than life coach. SMU was covering up rules violations to benefit players that were of little actual significance, save for the fact that they were breaking rules.

Penn State had a mafia type in house system where they did nothing to distance themselves from a man who had a negative impact on the lives of young boys that will affect them forever.

When I look at these types of events and I think about what has happened at Penn State, I just don’t think anything even approaches the magnitude of this scandal.

In terms of coverage and exposure, then I don’t think it can really even be argued. The whole country has been paying attention to this story unlike anything I’ve ever seen. This is also the most major sports story I can think of since the popularization of the internet, and certainly since the popularization of social media. These factors combined with ’round the clock news has led this story to unprecedented coverage out of the sporting world.


Categories: Commentary, NCAA, News, Sports

Tags: , ,

5 replies

  1. This ain’t a sport story.

  2. It’s a criminal story within a business which happens to be sports.
    Why not say it’s the biggest Pennsylvania story, or Midwest, or American, or college, or educational, or etc? We have no way of knowing who did what to whom when or if anything was done by anybody at anytime. We all want to believe everything we think happeded did in fact happen so we can be all self-righteous. The McMartin preschool guy 20 years ago spent like 8 years in prison and then it was revealed that all of the accusations were untrue. All colleges have been hiding all crimes from the public for years so that they wouldn’t scare off potential paying sutdents and their parents.
    It’s only the biggest scandal or crime of the century until the next one.
    Would it be less of a big story if he was the losingest coach in history, the middle-of-the-roadest coach in history? Is it the biggest sports story in history for the billions of people in the world who don’t care about sports or even know that Penn State exists?

    • The reason why it’s such a big story nationally is because it happened with an athletic program.

      I think that this is the biggest sports story ever. It is not necessarily the biggest story in the other categories you mentioned. For instance, it’s not the biggest Pennsylvania story ever. Other things, such as it being the birthplace of the Declaration of Independence trump the sports story.

      I do understand that Sandusky is innocent until proven guilty. But that doesn’t change the fact that there were allegations that were swept under the rug, and that even after these allegations, Sandusky still had minors on the campus and no one stopped him. At Sandusky’s own admission, he has showered with minors.

      While the McMartin trial lasted some seven years, there were never actually any convictions. The allegations were not all necessarily false, it’s just that no one was convicted. An acquittal doesn’t eliminate the possibility that crimes were committed.

      Colleges may have dirty laundy to one degree or another. The idea that “all colleges have been hiding all crimes from the public” is an unprovable conjecture.

      It’s not like the next huge sports story is going to occur next week that will top this. This is a very extreme circumstance. I don’t think that anything in my lifetime is even close to the level of this scandal (and as I explore in my piece, I don’t think anything ever has).

      The reason why the sexual abuse is a story is because of the context in which it happened. If these allegations were against Sandusky and he was a manager at a restaurant, it wouldn’t make national news. That’s why I view it as a sports story. The fact that Paterno is the winningest coach of all time and that this scandal led to his firing does indeed (in my opinion) contribute to why it’s such a major sports story. It’s tough to come up with analgoies: such as if he were the losingest coach of all time because – were he the losingest coach of all time – he probably would have been fired long before this story could have developed for several years.

      Also, I think it should be clear in context that I’m talking about American sports. I do realize that people in Indonesia don’t know or care about this story. They’re not my audience. Biggest American sports story ever.


  1. No excuses for Paterno: legacy forever ruined | Josh Benner

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: